The Dangers of Accreditation by Mary Hood, Ph.D.
As many of you know, I was the director of a home-schooling resource center in Kennesaw for many years. One of many reasons I shut down the center last June was that we were losing students to other places that claim to be "fully accredited." Since it has never been a requirement to be accredited in order to be admitted to Georgia colleges, this voluntary giving-away of parental control represents a very dangerous trend.
First of all, there is a large amount of misinformation floating around about what being "fully accredited" means. As an educational professional with a Ph.D. in education, I could personally start up something today that I could call an "accrediting agency for homeschoolers." The accreditation that I would offer, however, like any other accreditation, would not necessarily be worth the paper it was written on. The bottom line for any such accreditation, are the questions, "Who is a program accreditated by?, who accepts this accreditation, and for what purpose?" In the south, there are really only a few accrediting agencies fully accepted by all colleges. The most prominent of these is the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools. However, there have always been ways to enter college without such accreditation. It is true that "unaccreditated" programs including transcripts typed out by moms on a computer, will result in additional scrutiny of your portfolio, and, depending on the college, may cause inequitable treatment from the colleges. For those who are gallent enough to consider legal action, such treatment is clearly unconstitutional, based on the fourteenth amendment "equal protection of the laws clause." For those who are simply trying to get their students into college, however, remember that there are many routes to college. My oldest son could not get directly into the university system, due to lack of academic records, but wound up going in as a transfer student after the successful completion of thirty credits at a private shcool. However, four of my own children got directly into private Christian colleges (Toccoa Falls College and Shorter College here in Georgia, and William Carey College in Hattiesburg, Mississippi) without any accreditation whatsoever. Many, many of the students in our unaccredited diploma program have successfully applied for both public Georgia universities and other private colleges across the nation.
A secondary criticism of "unaccredited programs" here in Georgia is the supposed inability of homeschool students to get the Hope Scholarship. However, if you get into college and make a B average during your first thirty semester hours of work (generally one academic year), you get the scholarship retroactively and keep it as long as you continue to maintain a B average. Do you want to throw away all your control for a single tempting meal, like Esau did in the Bible?
One of the reasons I shut down the center was that, for the first time ever, I couldnít look someone in the eye and state that accreditation made absolutely no difference. This was due to the fact that the Hope grant (for dual enrollment purposes) was starting to be given out to accredited programs, and not to unaccredited ones. (This is not the same thing as the Hope Scholarship.) Before you run out to get accredited based on this fact, however, consider this: This is just the start of a downward spiral in terms of loss of parental control. If enough of you submit voluntarily to such accreditation, sooner or later, it will be required, and no one will be able to get into college or recieve the Hope scholarship without it. To those of you who are new, trust me. This is not paranoia. Remember, Iíve been around since the start of the movement and have personally witnessed the early struggles. Several of my friends wound up in jail in the early years! Also, I have a Ph.D. in education and travel around the country. Iíve personally seen the way other states have either watched their control gradually erode or decided to fight the good fight and stand their ground!
If you doubt me on this issue, call the admissions office of several colleges and ask them what their requirements are for home-educated students. Ask them if students need to be accredited in order to be admitted. Do your own research. Find out who these supposed accreditating agencies really are, who are on the boards of directors, and why they were formed in the first place.
In order to completely understand the dangers of accreditation, it might help to consider the current situation at the college level. Because it is already commonly accepted that "full accreditation" of college programs is required, several Christian colleges are in danger of being run out of business. For example, certain Christian colleges, which believe strongly in resisting the ways of the world, make a conscious decision to shun accreditation from the Southern Association. Since those colleges which have this accreditation are often not able to accept transfer credits from unaccredited schools, students may not be able to transfer from one school to another, including other Bible colleges, and may also have difficulty getting into certain graduate programs later.
For Christians who believe that they are responsible to God, rather than the government, this is already an unacceptable situation, and will only get worse if we start allowing ourselves to be concerned with accreditation on the high school level. Every time a homeschooling parent raises the issue of accreditation, or a homeschooling group submits to accreditation, it brings us that much closer to a day when high school will be like college. Some of the current supposed "accrediting agencies" claim to make few demands on parents. That may be true right now, but they are getting their toe stuck in the door. Next it will be a foot, then the whole leg. Sooner or later, if enough parents submit to such accreditation, none of us will be able to get into college without it. At that point, when we have lost our control over our education, I can promise you the demands will start. Among other things, once we have voluntarily submitted to accreditation, the next step will almost certainly be requiring accreditation from the Southern Association, which is virtually impossible to receive unless you are a bona fide school. At that point, Georgia parents will be in the same boat as many in other states, having to give up their control to educational professionals who may or may not understand the homeschooling scenario. What will come next? What about elementary and preschool? If we give up our hard fought freedom to direct the education of our children in high school without accreditation, we will all pay for it someday.
I donít believe homeschooling will ever again be illegal in this country. Weíve grown too big. Only if a dictatorship arose could it ever again go away completely. However, if the educational establishment can sink its claws into the movement through the "accreditation process," they wonít have to make us go away. They will be able to control us, require all of us to have college degrees and/or certification in order to teach our children, standardize our educational philosophies, standardize our textbooks and tests, and eventually remove God from home education just like theyíve already done in the government schools. Is "accreditation" really that important to you?
Mary Hood and her husband, Roy, have been homeschooling their five children since the early 1980s. The older children have successfully made the transition to college and adult life. Mary has a Ph.D. in education, and is a nationally-known speaker and the author of such books as The Relaxed Home School, The Joyful Home Schooler, and her latest The Enthusiastic Home Schooler. She is the director of the Assoc. of Relaxed Christian Home Educators and the ARCHERS high school diploma program. Check out the ARCHERS web site at www.archersforthelord.org.